ParaSummary Question 8 - CAT 2022
Passage: Several of the world’s earliest cities were organised along egalitarian lines. In some regions, urban populations governed themselves for centuries without any indication of the temples and palaces that would later emerge; in others, temples and palaces never emerged at all, and there is simply no evidence of a class of administrators or any other sort of ruling stratum. It would seem that the mere fact of urban life does not, necessarily, imply any particular form of political organization, and never did. Far from resigning us to inequality, the picture that is now emerging of humanity’s past may open our eyes to egalitarian possibilities we otherwise would have never considered.
A) The lack of hierarchical administration in ancient cities can be deduced by the absence of religious and regal structures such as temples and palaces.
B) Contrary to our assumption that urban settlements have always involved hierarchical political and administrative structures, ancient cities were not organised in this way.
C) The emergence of a class of administrators and ruling stratum transformed the egalitarian urban life of ancient cities to the hierarchical civic organisations of today.
D) We now have the evidence in support of the existence of an egalitarian urban life in some ancient cities, where political and civic organisation was far less hierarchical.
Step-by-Step Explanation
- Correct Answer: D
- Explanation: The passage shows that many of the earliest ancient cities operated successfully without kings, palaces, or administrative ruling classes, which proves that urban life does not automatically mandate hierarchical inequality. Option D precisely captures this by stating we now have evidence of non-hierarchical, egalitarian structures in some ancient cities.
- FundaMakers Tip: The Over-Generalization Filter. Option B asserts that ancient cities were not organized hierarchically, which applies a blanket rule to all of them. The passage says "Several of the world's earliest cities..." and "in some regions...", meaning the localized scope preserved in option D ("in some ancient cities") is correct.